Sir Keir Starmer has positioned himself as a leader who is willing to confront the UK’s long-term challenges head-on, tackling issues that have long been whispered about behind closed doors. His government is signalling a break from the status quo by addressing some of the “unsayable” truths in British politics—truths that politicians have historically avoided to protect their electoral prospects. But how much of this rhetoric can be turned into real, tangible action?
Facing the Tough Choices:
Starmer’s administration is setting a tone of candid pragmatism. A significant example of this is his decision to remove winter fuel payments from wealthy pensioners. For years, many politicians privately deemed it unnecessary to grant this benefit to those who don’t need it, but few dared to say it aloud—until now. Starmer’s stance signals a move towards rebalancing public finances in a way that prioritises need over tradition.
Moreover, he has been open about the trade-offs the public will need to accept for progress. Clean energy comes at the cost of more pylons near homes, and solving the housing crisis means local communities may need to embrace new developments. These are not easy policies to push, but they reflect a determination to address the UK’s infrastructure and environmental challenges head-on.
Social Care: The Elephant in the Room
One of the thorniest issues that Sir Keir has yet to fully grapple with is the overhaul of social care. Successive governments have dangled reform before pulling back, and Labour has, for now, paused its plans to cap social care costs. Many experts argue that the UK cannot fix the NHS without addressing social care first. The rapidly ageing population and increasing demands on public spending make this an unavoidable challenge. However, the question remains: when will Labour find the political and financial bandwidth to tackle it?
The Triple Lock: A Political Dilemma
Another significant issue is the triple lock on pensions—a policy guaranteeing that pensions rise each year by the highest of inflation, earnings growth, or 2.5%. While popular among pensioners, some politicians, even within the opposition, admit in private that it places a growing strain on public finances. The Labour Party, for now, has committed to maintaining the triple lock, likely recognising the political risk of alienating pensioners. Yet, with an ageing population, this promise will only grow more costly, raising questions about its long-term viability.
University Fees: The Unspoken Crisis
The question of university fees is another minefield. Over the past few decades, millions more young people have accessed higher education, transforming their lives and prospects. But the current funding model is unsustainable. Many universities are struggling financially, and without either higher fees or alternative funding sources, some may face closure. Yet no politician wants to tell young people that fewer of them should go to university. It’s a dilemma that continues to loom large, unresolved.
Tax Reform: The Unseen Inequity
Few political leaders openly discuss the inequities in the UK’s tax system. One glaring example is council tax, which is still based on 1991 property values. Despite calls from organisations like the Institute for Fiscal Studies to update this regressive system, no government has been willing to tackle it. It’s an issue that seems to be trapped in the “too hard” basket, with both Labour and Conservative governments shying away from a comprehensive revaluation.
What Lies Ahead for Starmer’s Government?
Sir Keir Starmer’s government has a massive majority, offering political stability that could allow for bold reforms. But even with this advantage, tackling the UK’s long-term issues is no easy task. Reforms come with costs—whether financial or political—and the balancing act between short-term political gains and long-term solutions will define this administration’s legacy.
Some observers argue that growth should take priority before embarking on costly reforms, a view that may influence Starmer’s strategy in his first term. While he has committed to addressing long-standing problems, the sheer volume of “unsayables” suggests that not every challenge will be tackled immediately.
Sir Keir Starmer’s government has a unique opportunity to bring the unsaid into the public arena, facing down long-standing political taboos. Whether it’s the overhaul of social care, reforming the pension system, or addressing university funding, the road ahead will require political courage and significant trade-offs. The question is: how many of these difficult decisions can Starmer’s government tackle in the coming years, and will the public be ready to accept the realities of reform?
Further Reading
