India is at the crossroads of a significant legal and social debate—whether or not to criminalise marital rape. The controversy stems from a centuries-old law, rooted in patriarchal traditions, that exempts husbands from being prosecuted for rape within marriage. Despite growing calls from activists and international organisations, the Indian government remains opposed to making marital rape a crime, claiming it would have far-reaching consequences on the institution of marriage.
The Ongoing Legal Battle
The Supreme Court of India is currently hearing petitions to amend Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), which states that a husband cannot be prosecuted for raping his wife unless she is a minor. This law, inherited from the British colonial era, has drawn widespread criticism for being outdated and unjust in the modern context.
According to a government survey, one in 25 women in India has experienced sexual violence at the hands of her husband. Campaigners argue that forced sex within marriage is still rape, irrespective of the relationship, and that India should join the more than 100 countries where marital rape has been criminalised, including the United Kingdom, which outlawed it in 1991.
Government’s Stance: A Socio-Legal Debate
In a 49-page affidavit, the Indian government opposed the petitions, stating that criminalising marital rape could have a negative impact on marriages. The government argued that marriage is a unique institution, with inherent expectations, including sexual relations, and that allowing a wife to retract her consent after marriage could destabilise families.
The government’s opposition has not surprised many, given India’s deep-rooted patriarchal norms. Marriages in India are often viewed as sacred, and any move to criminalise certain behaviours within marriage is seen as a threat to the traditional structure. Religious groups and men’s rights activists have also voiced their opposition, citing concerns that it would open up avenues for misuse of the law.
Divided Judgments and the Path Forward
The Indian judiciary has been inconsistent on this issue. In 2022, the Delhi High Court delivered a split verdict, leading to the case’s escalation to the Supreme Court. While some courts have allowed husbands to be tried for rape, others have dismissed such cases, citing the exemption provided under Section 375.
This inconsistency reflects the broader societal divide on the issue. While feminist groups and international human rights organisations such as Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the United Nations have condemned India’s stance, conservative factions argue that existing laws on domestic violence and sexual assault are sufficient to protect women.
Analysis: The Need for Legal Reform
The criminalisation of marital rape in India is not just a legal issue—it is a deeply entrenched social challenge. Indian society is undergoing a transformation, with increased awareness of women’s rights and autonomy. Yet, the laws have not kept pace with this evolution.
While the government argues that criminalising marital rape could “seriously disturb” marriages, this perspective overlooks the fundamental issue of consent. Marriage should not serve as a blanket license for sexual relations, and forcing sex upon a partner violates basic human rights.
The absence of legal recourse for marital rape sends a dangerous message: that women are not entitled to bodily autonomy within marriage. Criminalising marital rape would not only empower women but also serve as a deterrent against such violence, forcing society to confront its regressive attitudes towards marriage and gender roles.
India stands at a pivotal moment in its legal and social evolution. As more voices call for justice and equality, it is crucial that the nation re-evaluates its laws to reflect modern values of consent and human dignity. The debate over marital rape in India is not merely about legal definitions—it is a struggle for women’s rights and gender equality in a country that is rapidly modernising but still grapples with its patriarchal roots.
The Supreme Court’s decision on this matter will have profound implications for the future of women’s rights in India. If the law is amended, it could mark a significant victory for gender justice, setting a precedent for other countries where marital rape remains legal.
Further Reading
